With Nintendo, familiarity is key. They make good games, sometimes excellent ones, but it’s rare that an established franchise rocks the boat creatively. That’s why exceptions are noteworthy. And one of them is the Yoshi sub-franchise. Starting as a side-character in Super Mario World, Yoshi took centre-stage in its sequel and began a series of games that tested Nintendo’s limits. It hasn’t always worked, but we wouldn’t have interesting experiences otherwise.
Enter Yoshi and the Mysterious Book. Released this year, and developed by Good Feel Ltd., it has Yoshi filling the pages of an encyclopedia with strange creatures. It’s a chill game relying on vibes, but those vibes make the experience. How else would playing creature detective function? Especially when the challenge lies not in difficulty, but puzzle-solving and ingenuity?That’s what this game is. In one level, Yoshi grabs a water-like creature and blasts off. Another has Yoshi surfing the giant waves, nabbing gnarly tricks in the air. My favourite involves Yoshi getting coloured, alien-alike creatures to mate and create new variants. It’s weird, but it’s that weirdness that makes it worth your while.
Another element that compliments the vibe is the music. Yoshi’s previous entry, Yoshi’s Crafted World, was criticized for a musical motif that was badly arranged. I didn’t mind it, I thought it added to the charm, but minimal thought was put into how it sounded. This game seems to have learned from that. There isn’t much variety, but the tunes are pleasant enough to forgive that. As you progress through the pages, collecting information on various critters, Yoshi gains stars. The number of stars depends on completing certain objectives: is your creature edible? Can it sing? Does it glide majestically, or do you have to give it a push? The number of details per creature I discovered accidentally more than compensated for some challenges not clicking, as even the frustrating ones had perks.
Upon completing these challenges, you’re given the option to name the creatures. Personally, I kept going with the encyclopedia, Mr. E, and his suggestions. It’s lazy on my part, but I was never let down by his choices of names, particularly in the logic he used. It was either a pun, an extension of the creature’s behaviour, or based on a familiar character from the Yoshi franchise. Essentially, I doubt I’d have done better.
This encyclopedia comes in handy during the Bewilder Bird stages, as said bird can transform into any of the creatures. It’s here where your memory comes into play, as you’re forced to mix-and-match to beat the boss. Fortunately, swapping between creatures is straightforward, and there’s little to lose for getting it wrong. It’s not a cakewalk, especially since you need to think on your toes, but the low risk means your frustrations with failure are temporary. I like that. If I have any gripes with the levels, it’s that there are too many of them. Yoshi games being short isn’t new, Super Mario World 2: Yoshi’s Island only had six worlds, but I never thought my fight with a giant Bowser Jr., usually reserved for the final boss, would be the halfway point. This meant another six worlds to complete, and the final two were only unlocked by beating the game. It’s not a deal-breaker, but eventually I got tired of seeing a creature, exploring its habitat, naming it and moving on.
My only other critique is the final boss. It’s a tradition in Yoshi games for the final boss to first be a fight with Bowser Jr., then a more intense fight with a larger version. There have been exceptions, but that heart-pounding intensity was lacking here. Not that this final boss wasn’t fun, but I was disappointed to not have that particular battle. Still, I guess I can’t have everything I want…
Would I recommend Yoshi and the Mysterious Book? That depends on whether these games are up your alley. It also depends on if Good Feel Ltd., who made Kirby’s Epic Yarn and Princess Peach: Showtime!, is your jam. Having enjoyed both games a lot, I can safely say that I was on board with this one too. It may not be a standard platformer, but it’s certainly unique. And while no Yoshi game can fully live up to the franchise’s SNES days, no matter how creative, that doesn’t mean I don’t appreciate Nintendo taking big swings creatively with its prized dinosaur-horse hybrid…even if not every attempt proves a hit. But I guess that’s why this is a “vibes” game, right? The kind that relies on gimmicks and atmosphere, as opposed to a straightforward experience, right? There’s plenty I can say for this game being out-of-the-box creatively, including how it relies on exploration as opposed to challenge, but it’s the vibes that make Yoshi and the Mysterious Book what it is. That’s the key with vibes. It might not be for everyone, but if you can get past the storybook aesthetic you’re in for a treat. I know I was!




No comments:
Post a Comment