Before I begin, I want to address my anger and frustration at The Venice Film Festival over An Officer and a Spy. Like The Pianist, I’m sure it’s brilliant, but that’s irrelevant. Roman Polanski, the director, has been hiding in Europe following a statutory rape accusation, and he’s avoided charges since. By having his latest film receive accolades, it’s a form of enabling. It’s like no one cares that he’s a predator.
Still, while An Officer and a Spy received an ovation, the top prize actually went to Joker. Joker’s been touted as a potential Best Picture hopeful at the next Academy Awards, with Joaquin Phoenix a shoe-in for Best Actor. It’d be impressive that another comic book movie has a chance at the gold, but the movie’s controversies, including Phoenix losing 52 pounds, have turned-off many filmgoers. Also, its subject matter’s become the source criticism.
I get it. On one hand, melding mental illness and incel behaviour into a sympathetic portrayal of a psycho-killer is disturbing. Hollywood loves fetishizing and infantilizing the unwell, it’s practically its MO. It’s tiring to see them detract from conversations about mental health. And since several early reviews even acknowledged this, I’m more concerned than anything.
That said, I think people are being unfair. See, off-kilter individuals often make for good storytelling. It doesn’t always have to be that way, but crazy people allow for compelling forms of dark drama. And The Joker, Batman’s greatest nemesis, embodies that. Especially if Frank Miller’s The Killing Joke’s indication.
I strongly doubt that Joker’s intent is to ridicule depression and bipolar disorder. Todd Phillips, the director, was clearly inspired by Martin Scorcese, as evidenced by his casting of Robert De Niro. He may be delving into dark and unpleasant territory, as you’d expect, but his goal is to make a compelling drama. As are the writers and actors. And judging by reviews, they’ve largely succeeded.
Filmmaking, like all forms of narrative art, isn’t a perfect science. A story can be brilliant and still treat ideas with disdain, it happens regularly. To use examples of past Oscar nominees, The Dark Knight “fridged” its one female character of-note, while Black Panther can be read into as a CIA puff-piece. Both films are regarded as classics by critics and fans-alike, but they’re not always so sympathetic. No film can be fair to everything.
Joker’s no different: yes, it’s probably disturbing. And true, there’s a good chance it’ll divide people. But does that mean it’s undeserving of praise? No. I’m sure the film is still really good, otherwise it’d most-likely not receive that praise.
I get what the real issue is: it’ll inevitably fuel the internet dude-bros who feel like the movie “gets” them. It’s going to appeal to them most, become a meme for many years and generate a lot of real-world hate. And in the year 2019, when the leader of the world’s biggest superpower is a sociopath who actively spews hate, that’s a terrible reading of the global room. Joker, essentially, feels like it’s coming out at the wrong time.
But is that really the movie’s fault? Ignoring that the meme-train has already left the station, is it Joker that’s to blame for this behaviour? I’m not really one to talk, I’ve pointed fingers before at James Bond movies and The Matrix in the past, but Joker couldn’t have predicted this. Especially when works like The Matrix had their message skewed anyway.
I’m not kidding: think of all the pop-culture touchstones that’ve been misinterpreted by film nerds. The Matrix, a movie about not conforming to society’s toxic expectations, became a rallying cry for MRAs. Fight Club, which was about disseminating toxic masculinity, also became a rallying cry for MRAs. Even Star Wars, a franchise about fighting Space Nazis, is adored by actual Nazis, such that many people were upset when the newer films made the villains incompetent. (How many “The Empire Was Right” pieces do you think exist, after all?)
Joker being misread as praising vile behaviour would’ve happened regardless. And I think that that needs stressing. Besides, if the theatre shooting during the premiere of The Dark Knight Rises is indication, these behaviours don’t need specific catalysts to happen. All they need is a sociopathic, white supremacist jerk with an AR-15. It’s that simple.
Does this mean that Joker can’t be criticized? No. The movie won’t be perfect, and parts won’t be ideal. It also seems like DC and Warner Bros., in trying to make it “film snob-friendly”, are sanitizing it of its comic book elements. That last point bugs me the most, as, like with animation, comics will never be taken seriously. And given the box-office revenue of The MCU, that’s a slap in the face to reality.
But that doesn’t mean the movie won’t be worth people’s time. It might be, who knows? It isn’t available to the general public yet, and people’s minds can change. And isn’t that more important than ragging on a film for being too serious? Isn’t that what really matters? I don’t know about you, but I’d much rather a film say what it wants to, even at the expense of questionable subtext, then get shut out because it isn’t what people want right now.
Now, about An Officer and a Spy…
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts (Monthly)
-
Korrasami sucks, everyone. Honestly, I was debating how to start this one off: do I go for the verbose “Korra and Asami is a terrible f...
-
Is the book always better? This is a debate that’s been going on for a long time. So long, in fact, that you probably don’t remember its ori...
-
There’s plenty I can say about Agatha All Along . Like how it made me care for an antiheroine who murders other witches. Or how, despite bei...
-
I’ve been mixed on writing this for some time. I’ve wanted to on many occasions for 7 years, namely in response to the endlessly tiresome ra...
-
Another year gone, another year of reflection. Politics wise, it was the year of Donald Trump’s presidential hopefulness, Justin Trudeau ove...
-
It’s been rather rough this week. On Tuesday night, I spent the evening watching the American election results in real time. Despite not ant...
-
One of the annoyances about The Acolyte ’s cancellation is that the show wasn’t afraid to venture into new territory. For one, it came befo...
-
Last time, I ended with the following sentence: “If you’ll excuse me, The Boy and the Heron recently got added to Netflix...” Having now ...
-
Internet, it’s time we had a little talk. *Grabs the collective body by the ear and drags it to a private space* This is Frozen . I’m s...
-
So I rewatched Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse . Despite the behind-the-scenes involving the animators slightly diminishing my enjoymen...
Popular Posts (General)
-
Korrasami sucks, everyone. Honestly, I was debating how to start this one off: do I go for the verbose “Korra and Asami is a terrible f...
-
( Note: The following conversation, save for formatting and occasional syntax, remains unedited. It’s also laden with spoilers. Read at you...
-
It was inevitable that the other shoe would drop, right? This past month has been incredibly trying . On October 7th, Hamas operatives infi...
-
I recently watched a YouTube video deconstructing Howl’s Moving Castle . Specifically, it drew on The Iraq War parallels and how they held ...
-
(Part 1 can be found here .) (Part 2 can be found here .) At E3 2005, Nintendo announced their latest console . Dubbed “The Nintendo ...
-
Ableism’s an unusual kind of bigotry. It’s prevalent in how we communicate, and it shapes how we live our lives. The biggest offenders on a ...
-
On March 3rd, 2009, Warner Bros.’s animation division released an original, direct-to-video feature about comics’ prized superheroine, title...
-
I’ve been mixed on writing this for some time. I’ve wanted to on many occasions for 7 years, namely in response to the endlessly tiresome ra...
-
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm and I have a weird relationship. I’ve seen plenty of Batman films, being a huge fan of the character, but none...
-
This week marks the third in a period of the Jewish calendar called " The Omer ". That was one of the hardest sentences that ...
No comments:
Post a Comment